Pacha Shin Guard Evaluation
After seeing the finishing product of our creation we came to a conclusion that it wasn't what we expected to be. We thought that the shin guard would be a simple creation. But we found that the shin guards were uncomfortable if being used and also hard to shape to the leg of a person. We decided at the end of the evaluation that we are changing our product idea to a phone case.
Rubric
After seeing the finishing product of our creation we came to a conclusion that it wasn't what we expected to be. We thought that the shin guard would be a simple creation. But we found that the shin guards were uncomfortable if being used and also hard to shape to the leg of a person. We decided at the end of the evaluation that we are changing our product idea to a phone case.
Rubric
Criteria
|
Does not meet (0 Points)
|
Meets (1 Point)
|
Exceeds (2 Points)
|
Practical Use
|
You can not use it for anything.
|
Can use practically, but it is limited.
|
Very practical, and can be used in daily life.
|
Efficiency
|
Does not work the way the group wants it to.
|
Can work but not very well.
|
Works all the time for what is it suppose to do.
|
Appearance
|
Has no visual appeal.
|
Has some visual appeal to it.
|
Has a lot of visual appeal, and feels good in your hand.
|
Complexity
|
Very simple, only one part
|
Somewhat complex with multiple parts
|
Very complex, and has different parts to it.
|
Kanga: 2, 2, 2, 2. this group is making a speaker while no power, the idea is good, it works well, but the only problem is that the phone falls over if it gets moved at all.
Pioneers: 2, 1, 2, 1. this group is designing a phone charger support, while the idea is good, the design is very simple, but if it works it could extend the life pf a phone charger significantly.
SHU Makers: 2, 1, 1, 2. The SHU Makers are making bottle openers. At the moment the 3d printer material is not strong enough to open a bottle but they are planning on including a coin in their design to get more leverage while opening the bottle.
Team International: 1, 2, 2, 2. This team is making a new clip, they're doing this because they want to make one where it is hard for things to fall off the clip. This group's idea is alright the only problem is, I don't think that it will work that well, and it might be hard to use this every day.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1tK_G_N6KNjjNnZMwdL0EXRLQcbT1YWOqA7ThWawv32Y/edit?usp=sharing
Pioneers: 2, 1, 2, 1. this group is designing a phone charger support, while the idea is good, the design is very simple, but if it works it could extend the life pf a phone charger significantly.
SHU Makers: 2, 1, 1, 2. The SHU Makers are making bottle openers. At the moment the 3d printer material is not strong enough to open a bottle but they are planning on including a coin in their design to get more leverage while opening the bottle.
Team International: 1, 2, 2, 2. This team is making a new clip, they're doing this because they want to make one where it is hard for things to fall off the clip. This group's idea is alright the only problem is, I don't think that it will work that well, and it might be hard to use this every day.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1tK_G_N6KNjjNnZMwdL0EXRLQcbT1YWOqA7ThWawv32Y/edit?usp=sharing
What do you think the hardest part of these past 4 weeks (besides class time!)?
ReplyDeleteI think the hardest part of the past 4 weeks was perfecting the project. This caused us to change our project idea.
DeleteWhat went wrong with the shin guards that you had to change the idea?
ReplyDeleteWe found it really hard to mold to the players chin and also that it would break very easily.
DeleteWhat was your approach going from design to manufacturing phases in trying to produce the best result? Like what steps did you have to make in order to yield what you desired? What difficulties did you face?
ReplyDeleteWe actually completely changed our idea because it was much easier and more useful
DeleteWhat was inferior about the 3D printed shin guards to traditional shin guards?
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteHow did you decide what dimensions to make your shin guard in order to fit the curve of a shin?
ReplyDeleteWe tried molding it but it didn't really work so we ended up just changing our product completely
DeleteWould the shin guards have worked better if you had additional padding between the guard and the shin?
ReplyDeleteYes because it would be a lot safer for the player and it would be harder for the shin guard to break
DeleteIs that any sort of padding that could have been added to the guard to make it more comfortable or was it doomed from the start?
ReplyDeleteIf you could go back to redesign an aspect of the shinguard what would it be and why?
ReplyDeleteAlso will you be making different sizes for everyone to use?
ReplyDeleteIf we had followed up with this idea yes we would have mad a small, medium, and a large as shin guards are normally sold
Deletewhat made you change your idea of the shinguard to going with a phone case?
ReplyDeleteHow protective do you think the shinguard will be when used in an actual game?
ReplyDelete